Quantcast LiveSide - Windows Live news and interviews
LiveSide on the Windows Live Network LiveSide on Facebook LiveSide on Twitter LiveSide RSS  
Translate this page
MoFuse
LiveSide - News blog

Windows Live to replace Mail, Photo Gallery, and Movie Maker in Windows 7

Windows Live is set to take a much more prominent role with Windows 7, as Microsoft made it official today that Mail, Photo Gallery, and Movie Maker are being removed from the operating system, to be replaced by the free Windows Live services.

Of  course if you’ve been reading LiveSide, we’ve been telling you that since at least last March.  Then in June, Bill Gates hinted that Movie Maker “is Windows Live, now”, and Mary Jo Foley put 2 and 2 together a few weeks ago.

However Ina Fried from CNET received official confirmation from Brian Hall, Windows Live General Manager, today:

In a follow-up interview on Monday, Windows Vista general manager Brian Hall said Microsoft made the decision to remove the tools from Windows for several reasons, including a desire to issue new operating system releases more quickly than it has in the past. The move also removes the confusion of offering and supporting two different programs that perform essentially similar functions.

"It makes it much cleaner," Hall said.

The move makes sense to us on at least three fronts:  Windows gets physically smaller and also less of an anti-trust target; redundancy between Windows and Windows Live teams is lessened;  and the Live services can move at a faster pace without being tied to operating system time frames.  It will also potentially increase the reach of Windows Live, although it remains to be seen how the installation will be handled.  Buying an operating system without email abilities seems almost unthinkable, but will it be as easy to hook GMail into Windows 7 as Windows Live?  Lots more to come, and we expect to hear quite a bit more at PDC, coming up in a month and a few days.

Comments

yertthedestroyer wrote re: Windows Live to replace Mail, Photo Gallery, and Movie Maker in Windows 7
on 09-22-2008 9:18 PM

I think it is really sad that we heard this through Ina (no offense) rather then the e7 blog, or the WindowsVistaBlog.

Maybe blogging will go back into fashion at Microsoft, but until then we have LiveSide (and my blog too). And shameless self promotion of ourselves, don't forget that one. :P

surilamin wrote re: Windows Live to replace Mail, Photo Gallery, and Movie Maker in Windows 7
on 09-22-2008 9:35 PM

I think in today's world this is an absolutely necessary step.  We can't wait for a new OS release to get updates to certain software.  This will really help Microsoft move forward.

Windows Live team confirms: Win7 to replace subsystems with services | All about Microsoft | ZDNet.com wrote Windows Live team confirms: Win7 to replace subsystems with services | All about Microsoft | ZDNet.com
on 09-22-2008 10:12 PM

Pingback from  Windows Live team confirms: Win7 to replace subsystems with services | All about Microsoft | ZDNet.com

Windows Live substituir?? produtos do Windows 7 - Guia do PC wrote Windows Live substituir?? produtos do Windows 7 - Guia do PC
on 09-22-2008 10:59 PM

Pingback from  Windows Live substituir?? produtos do Windows 7 - Guia do PC

magicalclick wrote re: Windows Live to replace Mail, Photo Gallery, and Movie Maker in Windows 7
on 09-22-2008 11:27 PM

Finally, I have been waiting for this a long time now. The reason is the same as MS stated. Good to know they finally make it official.

New Microsoft, new cloud friendly Windows. Courageous and likable wrote New Microsoft, new cloud friendly Windows. Courageous and likable
on 09-23-2008 1:53 AM

Pingback from  New Microsoft, new cloud friendly Windows. Courageous and likable

tophtucker wrote re: Windows Live to replace Mail, Photo Gallery, and Movie Maker in Windows 7
on 09-23-2008 2:53 AM

There's no reason bundled applications can't be updated out of sync with OS releases, is there? I mean, look at Movie Maker... 2.0, the one and only major upgrade to date (discounting WLMM only because it seems so immature), came out of sync.

That said, I'm all for reducing redundancy and overlap between products. And everyone loves a lean, mean OS--except the guys doing the bullet points on marketing brochures.

But to ship 7 without a mail client or *photo viewer* seems dumb. I mean, WMP will still be bundled, no? Presumably we'll see a bare-bones photo viewer a la the XP photo viewer.

But I'd rather MS struck deals with OEMs to bundle these programs with new computers, making this change transparent to the end-user but still useful from an internal organizational standpoint. A download link (a la the Messenger dl link in Vista) just won't cut it. And it wouldn't be anticompetitive as long as the OEMs had a choice, right?

And then there's the Apple factor. They mock MS when they beef up the OS with extras, and it wouldn't surprise me if they mocked MS for shipping an OS without extras. But then, they shouldn't always call the shots....

DN2004 wrote re: Windows Live to replace Mail, Photo Gallery, and Movie Maker in Windows 7
on 09-23-2008 3:17 AM

I would imagine it will come standard with the operating system when it ships and the user would have the option to remove it if they wished. Like Liveside said this will cause MS to become a less anti-trust target. I wonder fi they will remove Windows Messenger as its kind of pointless considering Windows Live Messenger has richer features.

alsiladka wrote re: Windows Live to replace Mail, Photo Gallery, and Movie Maker in Windows 7
on 09-23-2008 4:26 AM

But if they release an OS which does not even support POP mails OOBE, a simple Photo Gallery, it would be criticized even more.

Instead, i would like them to add the installers to the Windows 7 setup, and not install by defalt. Instead of adding the download links in the welcome center, they should add installation links in the welcome center.

This way, instead of OEMs adding all the crap, even they could add installation links to the welcome center, and installing the apps could be left to the coice of the user.

WinAjuda » Windows Live substituir?? programas do Windows wrote WinAjuda » Windows Live substituir?? programas do Windows
on 09-23-2008 6:26 AM

Pingback from  WinAjuda  » Windows Live substituir?? programas do Windows

Microsoft sustituir?? Mail y otras aplicaciones por servicios Live en Windows 7 wrote Microsoft sustituir?? Mail y otras aplicaciones por servicios Live en Windows 7
on 09-23-2008 6:41 AM

Pingback from  Microsoft sustituir?? Mail y otras aplicaciones por servicios Live en Windows 7

Microsoft sustituir? Mail y otras aplicaciones por servicios Live en Windows 7 - Foro de Informatica para tod@s! - Foro de Windows Vista y Noticias de Informatica wrote Microsoft sustituir? Mail y otras aplicaciones por servicios Live en Windows 7 - Foro de Informatica para tod@s! - Foro de Windows Vista y Noticias de Informatica
on 09-23-2008 7:15 AM

Pingback from  Microsoft sustituir? Mail y otras aplicaciones por servicios Live en Windows 7 - Foro de Informatica para tod@s! - Foro de Windows Vista y Noticias de Informatica

GottaBeMobile wrote Windows Live Apps to Replace Cousins in Windows 7
on 09-23-2008 7:37 AM
zeke009 wrote re: Windows Live to replace Mail, Photo Gallery, and Movie Maker in Windows 7
on 09-23-2008 9:59 AM

Seems like a good idea to me.  Drop the last known good MSI for each Windows Live offering on the install media and give the user the option to load it or not or make it part of the welcome center in such a manner than any individual will notice it and load this software.

LiveSide - News blog wrote Windows Mobile 7 delayed, says Ina
on 09-23-2008 3:05 PM

Yesterday it was confirmation that Windows Live components would replace their Windows counterparts in

Nimbvs wrote re: Windows Live to replace Mail, Photo Gallery, and Movie Maker in Windows 7
on 09-23-2008 4:45 PM

Although OS integration is always a good idea -- and what with the fairly good and positive changes/pushes of the Live products -- what will keep the FTC and other such bodies from loading on Microsoft similar allegations/sanctions that they did on previous versions of Windows?  I hate to sound like a whiner, but hasn't Apple been doing this for a long time (OS integration  -- with iTunes, iPhoto, "iEtc."), with so much but a raising of eyebrows?

The volume of users notwithstanding, it's only a matter of time until smaller companies once again jump Microsoft for what can only improve the next version Windows.  What's Microsoft doing to safeguard the success of its next operating system in case any of its "bundled" improvements from claims of their being "monopolizing"?

Live products are good, and improving toward great, but will Microsoft's legal issues eventually hinder its ability to create a user-friendly, new-and-improved product vital to its very purpose as a software company?

Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness - Mashable wrote Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness - Mashable
on 09-23-2008 10:59 PM

Pingback from  Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness - Mashable

Mashable » Blog Archive » Windows 7 a dieta; gracias a Dios wrote Mashable » Blog Archive » Windows 7 a dieta; gracias a Dios
on 09-23-2008 11:43 PM

Pingback from  Mashable  » Blog Archive   » Windows 7 a dieta; gracias a Dios

Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness  »TechAddress wrote Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness  »TechAddress
on 09-23-2008 11:46 PM

Pingback from  Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness  »TechAddress

How to Get a Show on Revision3  »TechAddress wrote How to Get a Show on Revision3  »TechAddress
on 09-23-2008 11:47 PM

Pingback from  How to Get a Show on Revision3  »TechAddress

MySpace Launches a Self-Service Ad Solution; MySpace Music Can???t Be Far Behind  »TechAddress wrote MySpace Launches a Self-Service Ad Solution; MySpace Music Can???t Be Far Behind  »TechAddress
on 09-23-2008 11:48 PM

Pingback from  MySpace Launches a Self-Service Ad Solution; MySpace Music Can???t Be Far Behind  »TechAddress

Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness | World News wrote Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness | World News
on 09-24-2008 12:05 AM

Pingback from  Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness | World News

Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness « kNow Media wrote Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness « kNow Media
on 09-24-2008 7:35 AM

Pingback from  Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness « kNow Media

Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness | Latest Technology News - Business News And Expert Advice wrote Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness | Latest Technology News - Business News And Expert Advice
on 09-24-2008 7:45 AM

Pingback from  Windows 7 On A Diet - Thank Goodness | Latest Technology News - Business News And Expert Advice

Internet Marketing Specialist, SEO » Blog Archive » Windows Live team confirms Win7 to replace applets with services wrote Internet Marketing Specialist, SEO » Blog Archive » Windows Live team confirms Win7 to replace applets with services
on 09-24-2008 9:34 PM

Pingback from  Internet Marketing Specialist, SEO  » Blog Archive   » Windows Live team confirms Win7 to replace applets with services

Se reemplazar??n las aplicaciones por defecto por servicios de Windows Live wrote Se reemplazar??n las aplicaciones por defecto por servicios de Windows Live
on 09-25-2008 5:39 PM

Pingback from  Se reemplazar??n las aplicaciones por defecto por servicios de Windows Live

Windows Live Wave 3: What???s next? at GeekSmack News wrote Windows Live Wave 3: What???s next? at GeekSmack News
on 10-20-2008 4:21 PM

Pingback from  Windows Live Wave 3: What???s next? at GeekSmack News

LiveSide - News blog wrote Windows Live Wave 3: What’s next?
on 10-21-2008 3:38 AM

The Windows Live Wave 3 we’ve seen so far, with the exception of Calendar in Live Mail, has been pretty much an incremental upgrade, with performance enhancements and a new look, but nothing radically different (Messenger of course has included some new

Sign In Live ID using Live ID, Name/Password, or OpenID
or Join LiveSide to leave a comment!